I couldn't help but smile at his understated-but-still-devastating conclusion, starting with this paragraph:
The RCS technique used in the LW2005 MXD chronology eliminated high medieval values as a tautology of their method, not as a property of the data. The Icefields data provides equal (or greater) justification for MXD RCS chronologies with elevated medieval values.“…a tautology of their method...” indeed. Translated into language I might use, this says: “The LW2005 MXD chronology is bullshit!” – but he says it much more politely (and with better support) than I ever could. Do read the whole thing, and carefully – it's yet another Steve McIntyre masterpiece...
No comments:
Post a Comment