An Iraqi perspective

Ali of Free Iraqi — always an interesting read — has a fascinating new post. In it he develops a theory about how Iraqi (and Arab in general) perceptions are formed. He notes that Arabs tend not to ask questions, but to defer instead to authority, whereas Americans ask lots of questions. He then uses this obeservation to infer how Iraqi perceptions have developed. An excerpt:

After Saddam was toppled most Iraqis took a sigh of relief, "Now finally someone sane is going to run things here". They did think of America as a sane power totally replacing a mad one, at least for a while. I say they were relieved not just because they got rid of Saddam, as that meant incridible joy not relief. But It's been also a relief because it was scary to think that your fate is in the hands of an insane man while you can't do anything and you're not even used to such a huge responsibility.

But the Americans did not want to replace Saddam. They did not want to run things the way they wanted without sharing the responsibility with the people, even if they thought their management could fix things and even if this was for a transitional phace.An iron evil fist was gone but it was not replaced by an "iron good fist" as many Iraqis wished, and things collapsed in a place that has been ruled with extreme force for decades when people were given freedom.

This is one of the main reasons why many Iraqis were and still are disappointed with America. No, these Iraqis do not hate America as most like to think, they're just disappointed with her for not fitting the image they had in their minds; the just tyrant that should've taken full responsibility for some time until they could find their own just tyrant who would make their life much better without forcing them to share a burden and a responsibility they never thought it was among their duties as citizens.

Read the whole thing, not only for the perspective on Iraqis, but also for the window into how Americans look to some other cultures...